
London: Embattled liquor baron Vijay Mallya,
out on a 650,000-pound bail bond following his arrest by
Scotland Yard over fraud and money laundering charges earlier
this year, will return to Westminster Magistrates' Court in
London tomorrow as his extradition trial begins.
The 61-year-old businessman, who has been in self-imposed
exile in the UK since March 2016 when he left India, is wanted
in India on charges relating to his defunct Kingfisher
Airlines defaulting on loans from various Indian banks
amounting to Rs 9,000 crore.
The former Rajya Sabha member has told PTI during his
numerous court appearances in London over the last few months
that he has "done nothing wrong" and described the allegations
against him as "fabricated".
His defence team, led by barrister Clare Montgomery known
as an expert in criminal and fraud law with the UK s Matrix
Chambers, will now present his case in court.
"We are keen to draw a line under all the material
evidential and non-evidential," she had said during the last
case management hearing on November 20, when Mallya's defence
team presented a running order of expert witnesses to be
deposed in the case.
The trial is set to open with opening arguments, followed
by the witness statement of Dr B Humphreys, who is an aviation
expert.
Others expected to give their statements for the defence
include Margaret Sweeney, chief accountant at Force India
Formula One racing team, Professor Lau as an expert on the
Indian legal system, and Dr Alan Mitchell, a licensed medical
practitioner and a former medical officer with the Scottish
prison system.
It was Dr Mitchell s testimony that had a major impact on
another Indian extradition request in October, that of alleged
bookie Sanjeev Chawla a key accused in the cricket match -
fixing scandal involving former South African captain Hanse
Cronje in 2000.
That request was rejected after a trial at Westminster
Magistrates' Court on the grounds that Chawla's human rights
would be violated in Delhi's Tihar Jail under Section 87,
Article 3 relating to "prohibition of torture, or inhuman or
degrading treatment". The Indian government has sought
permission to appeal against the decision in the UK High
Court.
At a previous hearing in the Mallya case, Chief
Magistrate Emma Louise Arbuthnot had also highlighted prison
conditions as a concern that has been "raised in extraditions
to India before .
The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), arguing on behalf of
the Indian government, had told her that the Indian
authorities have foreseen this as an issue and have been
"engaged on the matter".
The CPS team, led by barrister Mark Summers who
specialises in extradition cases, highlighted "excellent
cooperation with the Indian authorities", who had provided
detailed assurances and photographs by email relating
to prison conditions where Mallya is to be held if he were to
be extradited to India.
The extradition trial itself, to be presided over by
Judge Arbuthnot, is listed for hearings until December 14,
with December 6 and 8 so far marked as non-sitting days. A
judgement in the case is not expected until early next year.
If the judge rules in favour of extradition at the end of
the trial, UK home secretary Amber Rudd must order Mallya's
extradition within two months. However, the case can go
through a series of court appeals before the actual
extradition order can be issued.
"The Crown Prosecution Service, acting on behalf of the
Indian authorities, will need to demonstrate a prima facie
case i.e. produce some evidence to show that the criminal
charges against Mr Mallya, for which his extradition is
sought, are justified," explains Jasvinder Nakhwal, partner at
Peters and Peters Solicitors LLP and member of the
UK's Extradition Lawyers Association.
India and the UK have an Extradition Treaty dating back
to 1992 but so far only one extradition has taken place from
the UK to India under the arrangement, that of Samirbhai
Vinubhai Patel wanted in connection with the post-Godhra riots
of 2002. But, unlike Mallya, he had submitted to
the extradition order without a legal challenge.
Mallya, who has been based at his Hertfordshire estate
called Ladywalk in the village of Tewin, around 30 miles from
London, had responded with a firm "no" on being formally asked
in court if he consented to being extradited to India on the
charges relating to his collapsed Kingfisher Airlines.
His extradition trial will now determine whether he can
be legally forced to go back to face the Indian courts.